En
+380 show number +38 095 19 19 190
Submit your application

You need to pay for heat, even if it is turned off in the apartment

Is the unauthorized disconnection of the apartment from the heating network a basis for canceling charges for heat? The Supreme Court of Ukraine, by a decision on case No. 522/401/15-c of 25/09/19, answered the question in the negative. The consumer is obliged to pay for the service that has not been consumed anyway!

Analyzing – why?

Initial situation: CE “Teploset …” goes to court with a claim against a consumer who does not pay for heating and hot water and therefore has a large debt. The court ruled that the demands of the heating network are fair, the appeal instance too …

In short, the solution was: “use – pay”!

The consumer did not agree with this and filed a cassation appeal with the Supreme Court of Ukraine. In the complaint, he asked the said decisions of the courts of previous instances to be canceled, arguing that he was right by the fact that the debt is not subject to collection, since:

  • the plaintiff missed the statute of limitations;
  • the consumer is disconnected from the heat supply networks;
  • it is impossible to conduct a legal analysis of the contract, since it does not exist.

The Ukrainian Supreme Court analyzed the circumstances of the case and established that it was true: there was no contract, the consumer was a defaulter who had arrears for heat and was unauthorizedly disconnected from the heat supply network. But, these moments are not a reason for non-payment, because …

“The obligation to pay for housing and communal services is regulated by a number of legal acts, a systematic analysis of the norms of which suggests that the absence of an agreement on the provision of services is not a reason for exempting the consumer from paying in full volume. Consequently, the absence of a treaty is not an argument for justice.”

The fact that the consumer unauthorizedly “cut off” from the heating network is generally a violation (Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine № 630 of 21.07.2005 prohibited to do this without permit). There is a special permitting procedure for disconnection, regulated by the “Disconnection Procedure…” approved by the order of the Ministry of Regional Development No. 4 dated November 22, 2005.

In the analyzed situation, “on the side” of the heating network, the Laws of Ukraine “On Housing and Utilities Services” and the Laws of Ukraine “On Heat Supply”, annulling the arguments of the cassation about that the consumer did not actually receive services, that means that charging for them is illegal.

The Ukrainian Supreme Court also spoke about missing the statute of limitations. The courts of the previous instances “did not notice” that it was interrupted, therefore, this justification of the cassation appeal is not taken into account.

The case was sent for review to the appellate instance, which must decide it taking into account the fact of the interrupted limitation period and with due justification of the court decision obliging the defendant to pay off the debt.

24.12.2019

253

YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN
SCU: matrimonial property is not always divided equally!

The Supreme Court of Ukraine, by its decision in case 308/4390/18 of 16.12.19, determined the aspects of deviation from the principle of equality of shares in the division of jointly acquired property of spouses. The fact of the presence of children living with the father (on his full support) and the mother, who does not […]

Appealing the decision of the Military Medical Commission (MMC)

The Military Medical Commission (MMC) is a body that conducts a medical examination of persons performing military duty and determines their suitability for military service. Sometimes such persons do not agree with the conclusions of the MMC, considering them unfounded. In such cases, there is a need to appeal the decision of the MMC. According […]

On “saving” confiscated housing by donating it to relatives

One of the “working” options for “saving” real estate from confiscation / foreclosure to pay off debts, the people have always considered the option of donating it to relatives through drawing up a donation agreement, the fictitiousness of which is quite difficult to dispute. Difficult, but possible! The Supreme Court of Ukraine published another legal […]

Remote participation of persons in court sessions

The participation of the accused (convicted) person in the trial by video link, can it be considered by law as direct personal? The answer to the question contains the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and this material. We analyze One of the innovations introduced in 2012 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine is the […]

Can two houses be built on one plot of land

Many landowners in urban outskirts often have the need to construct not just one but several houses on their land. Such requirements can have various reasons, and the key here is to correctly process all the necessary documents for the construction and legalization of these two houses on one plot. To address this issue, one […]

Challenging fraudulent agreements as a debt collection tool

Everyone who is engaged in business has at least once encountered a situation when an unscrupulous debtor begins to alienate his property in order to avoid paying the debt. This can happen in advance – even before the debt as such arises (property alienation occurs for no apparent reason and in the absence of obvious […]